10 Best “Red Sauce” Italian Restaurants in NYC

One of the questions I get asked a lot as a New York food blogger is:

“Yo. What’s a good ‘red sauce’ joint?”

This is roughly translated to: “excuse me, good woman, where is the best place to dine on classic Italian food, preferably with a flavorful tomato sauce?”

Now that you’re caught up, here are my picks below IN NO PARTICULAR ORDER. I am sure there are plenty of places I’m missing or forgetting too, so leave a comment with your suggestions! But from what little memory I have left, these are solid. Most recently I revisited Tony’s Di Napoli – family style Italian with two locations in Manhattan – and it didn’t disappoint. I took an order of ravioli bolognese home to my mom (below) and she said it was the highlight of her week. Just sayin.

NOTE: My lists are my own opinions (and occasionally the opinions of friends I trust). The phone numbers are links to the Google search for the restaurant because you’re welcome. Go forth, red sauce warriors.

Directions

  1. Vincent’s
    I love this place – it’s been around forever and I think they have some of the best sauce around. It comes in 3 varieties – sweet, mild, and spicy. When I was younger, I remember the spicy being like hell fire, though as I’ve grown, so has my tolerance for heat. But the original sweet sauce is fantastic, as is their vodka sauce if you want to stray from the “red sauce”.
    Menu
    119 Mott Street
    212-226-8133
  2. Tony’s Di Napoli
    As I mentioned above, family style Italian. This has been around a while too (est. 1959) and I think they make some of the best damn baked clams around. That and chicken parm – the red sauce is sweeter than you might be used to, but trust me it’s perfect on top of the crispy, cheesy chicken cutlet.
    Menu
    1081 3rd Ave New York, NY10065
    212-888-6333
  3. Deninos
    I revisited Deninos recently, and I have to say it’s just as good as it was when I went back in college. I was interning a few blocks away in the West Village and went there regularly for mozzarella sticks. Because college. Now I go for mozzarella sticks because #skinnypig. The marinara is still on point, as well as their pizza.
    Menu
    93 MacDougal Street New York, NY 10012
    646-838-6987
  4. Emilio’s Ballato
    This is a classic restaurant in NoHo that makes you feel like you stepped onto a scene in Goodfellas. Well, minus the violence. Very old-school and very delicious. Highly recommend.
    No Menu
    55 East Houston St New York, NY 10012
    212-274-8881
  5. Carbone
    Ok so let me preface this by saying, if you “got a guy” at Carbone, now is the time to use him. I love it here so much, but it’s VERY hard to get a reservation. It’s my personal belief they are trying to be the next generation of Rao’s. Like, book it months in advance. Or go for lunch. That’s usually how I get lucky here. It’s expensive but damn is it good. The meatballs, the garlic bread, and the spicy rigatoni vodka. That’s your dinner order and you’re welcome.
    Menu
    181 Thompson St New York, NY 10012
    212-254-3000
  6. Frank Restaurant
    This is my favorite of all the Frank Prisinzano restaurants (Sauce, Supper, and Lil Frankies). A tiny little gem on 2nd ave in the East Village pumping out some of the best “gravy” around. And for those of you who don’t know that term, it’s like that thick, Sunday sauce that’s cooked with various forms of meat to give it a rich, deep flavor. It’s the one that makes your tastebuds do a rendition of “Volare” when it hits your mouth. Don’t sleep on the garlic bread and burrata here either.
    Menu
    88 2nd Ave New York, NY 10003
    212-420-0202
  7. Rao’s
    I’ve never been here which is really sad but I know for a fact it’s supposed to be amazing. Since 1896. Just let that sink in. You need to find someone who “has a table” or find that guy who got you into Carbone. I bet they know the same people. Or maybe there’s some trick to getting in but I sure as shit don’t know it so sorry I can’t be of more help there.
    No Menu
    445 East 114th St New York, NY 10029
    212-722-6709
  8. il Mulino
    I think my favorite part about dining at il Mulino are the little extras given to your table at no cost (though to be fair, it’s an expensive place). Cheese, bruschetta, fried zucchini…all come to you before you even get to your meal. And it’s been around since the 80’s so you know it’s good if it can outlast that decade.
    Menu
    86 West 3rd Street, New York NY 10012
    212-673-3783
  9. John’s of 12th Street
    Literally over 100 years old, you can’t go wrong with a meal here. The homemade pasta, the sauce, and OH MY CHRIST the meatballs. Like meat pillows. Just give it a shot and thank me later.
    Menu
    302 East 12th St, New York NY 10003
    212-475-9531
  10. Patrizia’s
    Last but most definitely not least, shout out to my other favorite family style Italian! The original Patrizia’s in Williamsburg, BK has been a favorite of mine (and my Queens crew) for probably a decade. We would organize a dinner here once a year or so, and just FEAST on eggplant parm, calamari, pizza, chicken parm, and the little “purse” pasta in a mushroom cream sauce. DROOL. Did I mention they do a prix-fixe option with unlimited wine too? It’s honestly heaven and they have one in Manhattan now, as well as Massapequa Park for all you Long Islanders. You’re welcome.
    Menu
    5868 35 Broadway, Brooklyn NY
    718-218-9272

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*